2:45 Musselburgh: 1m Class 5 handicap
Hibernian FC Emerald Club Handicap Stakes
An ordinary Class 5 mile on good to soft. The best of the form comes from Tolstoy's Class 4 runs and the strong Doncaster race it won, ahead of a group of Scottish-based handicappers led by course winner Empirestateofmind and Motawaared. It looks open beyond the top two or three, with several runners that have to prove themselves at the trip or on turf.
The runners
In order of our rating, best first. The rating is in pounds, so the gap says how far behind the top each one is: a 2lb race is open, a 10lb race is not. Press Form on any horse for its runs, the case for and against, and what suits it. Prices as at 08:00.
14(5)Tolstoy h001733 · Dale Swift · Brian Ellison7376top5/1Best form in the race.class dropwinning mark
Won 11 Sep Doncaster Class 5 1m off OR 70 from Feel The Need and Caragio, who have won 3 races between them since, while Nyman, 3¾L behind, won a Class 2 off OR 73. It then ran 3rd beaten 1¼L at York Class 4 on 9 Oct, with Quest For Fun and King's School behind it going on to win C4s off OR 77 and OR 74. It was 3rd again at Doncaster Class 4 on heavy on 24 Oct, beaten 2L after coming from the back. It is OR 73 today, close to the OR 70 it won off, and has won 2 of its 8 races at this trip. Quiet Resolve, beaten 24¾L by it at Doncaster on 11 Sep, is 7lb better off.
Drops to Class 5 and steps back up to 1m, off OR 73 in a hood, on ground it has handled.
Has missed the break more than once lately and has never run at this course.
Our figure (in testing): 1st of 10. The read has him 1st.
5 earlier runs
21(10)Empirestateofmind b012123 · Jason Hart · John & Sean Quinn7574-23/1Solid and proven here, but the mark is now high enough to stop it.class dropc & d
Won 18 Sep Ayr off OR 67 and 29 Sep Ayr off OR 71, holding Motawaared by ¾L in the second of those. It was beaten ½L at Ayr 7f off OR 71 on 8 Oct, then 3rd of 10 beaten 9L at Haydock Class 3 off OR 75 on heavy. It has won 2 of its 2 races at this course and 4 of its 28 at this trip, including a Class 2 win at York off OR 87 on 11 Oct 2024. Motawaared is 3lb worse off for that Ayr defeat, and Good Morning Alex, beaten 5L by it at Ripon on 16 Apr, is 1lb worse off.
Back to Class 5 at 1m in blinkers, off OR 75, at a course where it is unbeaten in 2 runs.
Its winning marks this autumn were 71 and 67, and it runs off 75 from draw 10.
Our figure (in testing): 2nd of 10. The read has him 2nd.
5 earlier runs
39(4)Motawaared p225213 · Lauren Young(5) · Jim Goldie6472-47/2In form and well handled by the claim, but it keeps finding one too good.
Beaten ¾L by Empirestateofmind at Ayr on 29 Sep and 3lb worse off today. It then won at Ayr over 1m2f on heavy off OR 60, coming from last after missing the break. Last time it was 3rd beaten 2L over 1m1f here off OR 62, again after a slow start. It has run 6 times at this trip without winning (4 placed) and 7 times at this course without winning (4 placed). Good Morning Alex, beaten 3½L by it here on 12 Sep, is 8lb better off.
Drops to 1m off OR 64 with Lauren Young claiming 5lb, in cheekpieces.
Keeps missing the break and has yet to win at a mile or at this course.
Our figure (in testing): 3rd of 10. The read has him 3rd.
5 earlier runs
45(1)Good Morning Alex500510 · Oisin Orr · David & Nicola Barron7270-610/1If it repeats the Hamilton run it is good enough to win this.class drop
Won 20 Sep Hamilton Class 4 1m½f on heavy off OR 70, beating Rajapour (OR 84) by a short head with Maximising (OR 84) ½L back. Maximising won a Class 3 off OR 84 next time, and Vincenzo Peruggia, 4L behind, won a Class 4 off OR 82. It was then 10th beaten 19L at Class 3 on soft on 28 Sep. It has won 7 of its 19 races at this trip and is OR 72 today. Beaten 3½L by Motawaared here on 12 Sep, it is 8lb better off, and it is 1lb worse off with Empirestateofmind for a 5L defeat at Ripon on 16 Apr.
Drops from Class 3 to Class 5 and back to 1m, off OR 72 from draw 1.
Its recent form is erratic and it was well beaten in its only run at this course.
5 earlier runs
57(6)Cavallo Pazzo tv76-811 · Shane Gray · Daragh Bourke6569-79/2In form but has plenty to prove in these conditions.winning mark
Won Class 6 races at Newcastle-AW over 7f off OR 55 on 16 Oct and off OR 65 on 30 Oct, the second while travelling easily. Neither race has worked out yet. On turf it was 8th beaten 8¼L at Ayr on soft on 17 Sep off OR 57, in a race that has thrown up 6 winners. It has run 2 times at this trip without a placing and has never run at this course.
Up in class and trip off OR 65 in a tongue tie and visor, on its first run at this course.
Its wins came at Class 6 on the all-weather over 7f, and today is Class 5 on turf at a mile.
Our figure (in testing): 4th of 10. The read has him 5th.
5 earlier runs
66(2)Barley p401360 · David Allan · Tim Easterby7068-87/1Capable of a place but a poor finisher.
Won 9 Sep Carlisle Class 5 1m off OR 68, but nothing from that race has won since. It was 3rd beaten 2¼L at Ayr on soft on 17 Sep, then 6th beaten 3¾L in a Class 2 at Redcar on 3 Oct carrying 120lb. Last time it was 12th beaten 12¼L at Newmarket, held up and never involved. It has won 2 of its 41 races at this trip, with 19 placings. Empirestateofmind, behind it at York on 6 Sep, is 3lb worse off, and Quiet Resolve is 2lb better off for the Ayr run.
Same class and trip, off OR 70 in cheekpieces from draw 2.
Has won only 2 of 41 at the trip and was well beaten in its one run at this course.
Our figure (in testing): 5th of 10. The read has him 6th.
5 earlier runs
72(9)Ablon215631 · Paul Mulrennan · Richard Hannon7567-911/1Progressive, but the drop in trip is a real question.
Won 14 Oct Kempton-AW Class 5 1m3f off OR 70, but only 1 runner from that race has run since. It was 3rd beaten 1L at Bath over 1m2f on 8 Oct. At Newbury on 2 Jul it was 5th beaten 1¾L in a race that has produced 8 winners since, with James Choice, 1¾L behind, later winning off OR 75. It has run 2 times at this trip without winning, finishing 2nd at Kempton-AW in 11 Feb, and runs off OR 75 today.
Class 5 at 1m off OR 75 for Richard Hannon and Paul Mulrennan, on its first run here.
Drops 3f in trip, is up in the weights, and has never run at this course.
Our figure (in testing): 8th of 10. The read has her 7th.
3 earlier runs
83(8)Izzari281418 · Cara Tuke(7) · Iain Jardine7566-1014/1The claim helps, but the mark looks too steep.c & d
Won at Southwell-AW off OR 62 on 26 Sep and off OR 66 on 10 Oct. In the second of those, Sandy Craic, 4½L behind, won a Class 5 off OR 69 next time. Last time it was 8th beaten 4½L at Southwell-AW off OR 75, after missing the break and being short of room. It won its only race at this course, off OR 66 on 13 Apr 2025, and has won 3 of its 13 races at this trip. Empirestateofmind is 4lb better off for their Newcastle meeting on 25 Jul, and it is 4lb worse off with Quiet Resolve for their Hamilton meeting on 3 May.
Back on turf at a course where it has won, off OR 75 with Cara Tuke claiming 7lb.
All its recent form is on the all-weather, and it is now rated 75.
5 earlier runs
98(7)Quiet Resolve b620990 · Tom Eaves · Alan Brown6660-1633/1Needs a big return to form.winning mark
Its last 4 runs were 12th, 9th, 9th and 10th, beaten between 5½L and 24¾L. That includes a 24¾L defeat behind Tolstoy at Doncaster on 11 Sep, for which it is 7lb better off today. It won off OR 68 at Hamilton on 3 May and is down to OR 66, with 2 wins from 27 races at this trip. Its one run here was 2nd of 4 in 6 Nov 2024. It is 2lb better off with Barley for the Ayr meeting on 17 Sep.
Class 5 at 1m off OR 66 in blinkers, a mark close to its last winning one.
Shows no current form.
Our figure (in testing): 10th of 10. The read has him 9th.
5 earlier runs
1010(3)Escape Act0003-7 · Andrew Mullen · Jean McGregor5658-1825/1Hard to see it winning.winning mark
Was 7th beaten 4½L at Musselburgh Class 6 7f on 30 Sep. Jkr Cobbler, 1¼L behind it that day, won a Class 6 next time. Before that, its recent form was in Ireland in 2 Jul 2025 and 25 Apr 2025. It has won 1 of its 9 races at this trip, a Class 5 at Doncaster on soft off OR 66 back on 11 Jul 2024. It carries 116lb off OR 56.
Up to Class 5 and 1m off OR 56, near the bottom of the weights.
Has done little in a long time and steps up in class.
5 earlier runs
How to read this table
Rating is the read's own figure for each horse today, in pounds on one scale for the race. Our figure, a separate mechanical rating, is in testing and shows inside each horse's form until it has a record worth showing.
Days is days since the horse last ran. OR is its official rating. A small letter after the name is headgear (b blinkers, v visor, p cheekpieces, t tongue tie, h hood).
Key form lines
The past races that say most about this one, and what they mean today.
A Class 5 mile that threw up 5 later winners, including a Class 2 winner, so Tolstoy's win in it is strong Class 5 form at today's trip.
Tolstoy was beaten 1¼L in a 20-runner Class 4 and finished ahead of two subsequent Class 4 winners rated 77 and 74.
Good Morning Alex beat two horses rated 84, one of which won a Class 3 next time, which is better than anything else in its recent record.
Empirestateofmind held off Motawaared by ¾L on heavy; Motawaared, who won next time, is 3lb worse off today.
Where today's runners have met
Races two or more of today's runners have run in, the last 18 months first. "Terms" shows how the weights have moved since, against the best-placed of them that day.
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 4th | — | the yardstick |
| Good Morning Alex | 5th | 5L | 1lb worse off |
| Barley | 8th | 10¾L | 2lb worse off |
The others in that race, since
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Motawaared | 2nd | ¾L | 3lb worse off |
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 2nd | — | the yardstick |
| Motawaared | 5th | 11L | 3lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Motawaared | 2nd | 1L | 3lb better off |
10 more meetings
| Finished | Behind Barley | Terms v Barley | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barley | 3rd | — | the yardstick |
| Quiet Resolve | 9th | 15L | 2lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Motawaared | Terms v Motawaared | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motawaared | 2nd | — | the yardstick |
| Good Morning Alex | 5th | 3½L | 8lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Tolstoy | Terms v Tolstoy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tolstoy | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Quiet Resolve | 12th | 24¾L | 7lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Barley | Terms v Barley | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barley | 13th | — | the yardstick |
| Empirestateofmind | 15th | 4L | 3lb worse off |
| Finished | Behind Izzari | Terms v Izzari | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Izzari | 9th | — | the yardstick |
| Empirestateofmind | 10th | 1¼L | 4lb better off |
The others in that race, since
| Finished | Behind Motawaared | Terms v Motawaared | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motawaared | 7th | — | the yardstick |
| Good Morning Alex | 10th | 3¼L | 6lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Quiet Resolve | Terms v Quiet Resolve | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quiet Resolve | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Izzari | 8th | 12½L | 4lb worse off |
| Finished | Behind Quiet Resolve | Terms v Quiet Resolve | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quiet Resolve | 6th | — | the yardstick |
| Motawaared | 7th | 1¼L | 8lb better off |
The others in that race, since
| Finished | Behind Izzari | Terms v Izzari | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Izzari | 3rd | — | the yardstick |
| Quiet Resolve | 5th | 2¾L | 14lb better off |
The others in that race, since
| Finished | Behind Barley | Terms v Barley | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barley | 2nd | — | the yardstick |
| Quiet Resolve | 8th | 13½L | 1lb better off |
Earlier meetings: 4 races before 4 May 25, newest first
| Finished | Behind Barley | Terms v Barley | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barley | 5th | — | the yardstick |
| Good Morning Alex | 6th | ½L | 2lb worse off |
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 9th | — | the yardstick |
| Tolstoy | 10th | ¾L | 2lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Barley | 3rd | 1½L | 1lb worse off |
| Finished | Behind Empirestateofmind | Terms v Empirestateofmind | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Empirestateofmind | 21st | — | the yardstick |
| Tolstoy | 28th | 9½L | 3lb better off |