1:10 Musselburgh: 1m4½f Class 6 handicap
Burton Roofing Merchants Handicap Stakes (Div I)
A modest Class 6 handicap with four horses who have recent form at or near their marks and little depth behind them. It is open: none of the principals has a run that clearly separates it from the others at this trip on this ground.
The figure and the read. Flying Moonlight tops our figures largely through its 3rd over 1m at Ayr on 8 Oct, yet none of the 6 runners from that race to run again has won. Grey Fable has twice finished within ¾L of Mr Moonshine, who won off OR 66 next time, and runs off 59 in a lower grade. The figures put most weight on Grey Fable's 6th on soft to heavy at Bellewstown, while I lean on its Beverley and Chester runs at the trip on good ground, where those rivals have since won.
The runners
In order of our rating, best first. The rating is in pounds, so the gap says how far behind the top each one is: a 2lb race is open, a 10lb race is not. Press Form on any horse for its runs, the case for and against, and what suits it. Prices as at 08:00.
13(9)Grey Fable t195426 · Jason Hart · Karl Thornton5962top4/1Its best lines at the trip are stronger than anything else in the race.
Its best recent lines are at the trip on good ground in Class 5. At Beverley on 13 Aug it was 2nd, beaten 4¾L by Wardlaw, who has since won a Class 3 off OR 77; Mr Moonshine was a neck behind and won off OR 66 next time. At Chester on 25 Jul over 1m4½f it was 4th, beaten ¾L, with Mr Moonshine ½L ahead, and 10 from that race have run again for 2 winners and 7 placings. Since then it was 6th of 11 beaten 4¾L at Bellewstown on soft to heavy, with Acanto 1½L ahead placing since, and 5th over hurdles. It won off OR 56 at Dundalk on 26 May, has won 1 of 10 at the trip and has not run at this course.
Back to 1m4½f on the Flat from a 2m hurdle, in a tongue tie, off OR 59 on good to soft.
It pulled hard and made the running in both its good runs, and its last run was a tame effort over hurdles.
5 earlier runs
29(4)Flying Moonlight p-33243 · Greg Fairley · Sandy Thomson5061-12/1A consistent, improving type that could well step forward for the longer trip.first-time gear
Its one run at the trip was at Hamilton on 20 Sep on heavy: 4th of 6 beaten 3L, with Uncle Liam ½L ahead placing next time and Storm On Jura 3L ahead going on to win at this course off OR 48. Before that it was beaten a neck off OR 48 over 1m2f at Ayr on 8 Aug, in a race that has produced 2 winners. Last time it was 3rd beaten ¾L over 1m at Ayr on 8 Oct on heavy, but 6 from that race have run again without a winner. It runs off OR 50 in first-time cheekpieces and has not raced at this course.
Up 4½f in trip, first-time cheekpieces, off OR 50 on good to soft, with no previous runs here. First time in headgear.
Its only run at the trip did not go beyond its mark, and its top recent figure comes from a race that has not worked out.
Our figure (in testing): 1st of 11. The read has him 2nd.
3 earlier runs
31(1)Naturalia418443 · Andrew Mullen · Donald Whillans6460-211/2Proven at the course and trip and dropping in grade, so it is very much in the mix.class drop
It is the highest rated in the race on OR 64. In Class 5 it was 3rd beaten 4½L at Doncaster on 23 Oct on heavy, and 4th beaten 4¼L at Ayr on 8 Oct after being short of room. In that Ayr race Sweet Kiss, 1¼L ahead, won next time off OR 60. It won off OR 62 at Ayr on 10 Aug with Parole Officer 6th, and on 22 Jun was beaten a neck over this course and trip off OR 62. At the trip it has won once and placed 4 times from 7, and here it has placed in 2 of 3.
Down to Class 6 and up to 1m4½f, a trip it has placed at here, off OR 64 with 140lb on good to soft.
It carries top weight off a mark above the one it last won off, and has not won since 10 Aug.
Our figure (in testing): 3rd of 11. The read has her 3rd.
5 earlier runs
42(3)Kartini065471 · Paul Mulrennan · Simon Whitaker5559-34/1In form, but it has questions to answer over the extra distance.winning mark
It won at Redcar on 26 Oct on heavy by 3½L from Dandy's Angel, pulling well clear, off OR 55, the mark it runs off today. Only 1 from that race has run again, without placing. Dandy's Angel is 5lb better off and Parole Officer 6lb better off with it today. Earlier, its 4th beaten 7½L at Pontefract on 17 Sep came in a race that has produced 3 winners, including Grindleton and Rory's Gold, who both finished ahead of it. It has no runs at this trip and none at this course; all its recent runs were over 1m2f.
Up 2½f in trip on good to soft off an unchanged OR 55, with no course experience.
It has never raced beyond 1m2f, and the Redcar win came on heavy ground.
5 earlier runs
58(2)Dandy's Angel p662625 · Tom Kiely-Marshall(3) · John Wainwright4754-816/1Its recent form ties it closely to Kartini, and it is in good heart.winning mark
Beaten 3½L by Kartini at Redcar on 26 Oct on heavy, it is 5lb better off with that rival today. It then ran 5th of 15 beaten 5½L at Nottingham on 28 Oct on soft. It was 2nd beaten 2¾L over 1m3f at Hamilton on 2 Sep on soft, but 6th of 6 at Hamilton on 20 Sep, where Flying Moonlight was 4th; it is 2lb better off with that rival. It runs off OR 47 with a 3lb claim, last won at the trip off OR 52 on 30 Sep 2024, and has won 1 and placed 3 times from 7 at the trip.
Up 2½f to a trip it has won at, off OR 47 with a 3lb claim, in cheekpieces, on good to soft.
It is a 9yo whose best recent runs came on soft or heavy ground, and its one run here was in 2020.
Our figure (in testing): 5th of 11. The read has her 5th.
5 earlier runs
610(11)Parole Officer b906505 · William Pyle · Ewan Whillans5050-1220/1It needs the step up in trip to bring out more than it has shown so far.
Its closest recent run was 5th of 12 beaten 3½L at Newcastle on 2 Sep, where New Objective (¾L ahead) and Dalamara (2L ahead) both won next time. It was 5th beaten 13¼L behind Kartini at Redcar on 26 Oct and is 6lb better off with that rival. It was 6th beaten 4¼L by Naturalia at Ayr on 10 Aug and is 4lb better off with that one. It runs off OR 50 in blinkers, has never raced at this trip, and its only run here was 9th of 10 over 1m.
Up 2½f to a trip it has not tried, in blinkers, off OR 50.
It fights for its head in its races, which is a worry over a longer trip.
Our figure (in testing): 6th of 11. The read has him 6th.
5 earlier runs
77(8)Cougar b557908 · Joanna Mason · Nick Kent5046-1633/1It likes the course, but its current form is too poor to make a case.winning markc & d
It won over this course and trip on good to soft on 14 Sep 2025 off OR 51, runs off OR 50 today, and has won 2 of 8 at the trip. Its recent form is poor: 8th beaten 21¾L at Leicester on 26 Oct on soft, 10th of 11 at Southwell after missing the break, and 9th of 9 at Southwell on 17 Sep. That 17 Sep Southwell race has produced 3 winners since, but Cougar was tailed off in it. It was 9th at Hamilton on 15 Jun 2025 with Dandy's Angel 13th, and the pair meet on the same terms today.
Back at a course and trip where it has won, in blinkers, off OR 50.
It has been well beaten in each of its last four runs.
Our figure (in testing): 7th of 11. The read has him 7th.
5 earlier runs
85(7)Kinross Claret/63-70 · Oisin Orr · Lucinda Russell & Michael Scudamore5644-1812/1It needs a big improvement on its last run.
It was 14th of 18 beaten 49½L at Doncaster on 23 Oct on heavy, outpaced throughout, in the race where Naturalia was 3rd; it is 7lb better off with Naturalia today. Its better run was 7th of 22 beaten 6½L over 1m at Doncaster on 29 Mar, a race that has produced 11 winners since. It has never run at this trip or at this course. It runs off OR 56.
Up 2½f to an untried trip, off OR 56, on good to soft rather than heavy.
It has shown nothing in its only run since the spring.
Our figure (in testing): 8th of 11. The read has him 8th.
911(10)Galistra507909 · Rhys Elliott(5) · Alan Brown4540-2250/1Hard to make a case for it on any of its form.
It was 9th of 11 beaten 6¾L over this trip at Newcastle on 19 Sep, in a race whose runners have done little since bar Fairydale. Before that it was 12th of 12 beaten 56L at Newcastle on 2 Sep behind Parole Officer, and it is 1lb worse off with that rival today. It has run 4 times at the trip without placing, including in Class 3. It runs off OR 45 with a 5lb claim and has not run here.
Same trip as last time, off OR 45 with a 5lb claim, on turf.
It has not placed in any of the recent runs listed.
Our figure (in testing): 9th of 11. The read has her 9th.
3 earlier runs
106(6)Miss Veronika4660 · Dale Swift · Brian Ellison5236-2622/1It has a great deal to find.
It was last of 14, beaten 194¼L, over 1m4f at Southwell on 24 Oct after struggling from the outset. Before that it was well beaten over sprint trips at Catterick and Southwell. Its best run was 4th of 9 beaten 9¾L over 7f at Newcastle on 20 Aug, where it stayed on. It has run once at the trip without placing, has not run here and is rated OR 52.
Up ½f in trip, off OR 52, and on turf after the all-weather.
It has shown no form in any recent run.
Our figure (in testing): 10th of 11. The read has her 10th.
1 earlier run
114(5)Battosai b453500 · Sam James · Jack Morland6235-2711/1It needs the step back up in trip to spark a complete revival.
It was last of 14 beaten 34L at Kempton on 9 Sep and 13th of 14 beaten 45¼L there on 10 Aug, both over 1m. Its last run near this trip was 3rd of 4 beaten 7¼L over 1m4f at Chepstow on 3 Jul off OR 71, in a race where Last Verse has since won off OR 75. It runs off OR 62 in blinkers, has 1 placing from 2 runs at the trip, and has not run here.
Up 4½f in trip, back to the sort of distance where it placed at Chepstow, in blinkers, off OR 62.
Its form has fallen away badly since early summer.
Our figure (in testing): 11th of 11. The read has him 11th.
5 earlier runs
How to read this table
Rating is the read's own figure for each horse today, in pounds on one scale for the race. Our figure, a separate mechanical rating, is in testing and shows inside each horse's form until it has a record worth showing.
Days is days since the horse last ran. OR is its official rating. A small letter after the name is headgear (b blinkers, v visor, p cheekpieces, t tongue tie, h hood).
Key form lines
The past races that say most about this one, and what they mean today.
Grey Fable ran close to two horses who have since won off OR 77 and OR 66, so it is capable of form above its mark of 59.
Over 1m4½f, Grey Fable was beaten ¾L with Mr Moonshine ½L ahead, which backs up the Beverley line at today's trip.
Kartini won well on heavy, but only 1 from the race has run again; Dandy's Angel is 5lb better off and Parole Officer 6lb better off with it today.
Flying Moonlight's only run at the trip was a 3L 4th on heavy, with Storm On Jura, who finished ahead of it, winning here since off OR 48.
Naturalia was beaten a neck over course and trip off OR 62, so these conditions suit it.
Where today's runners have met
Races two or more of today's runners have run in, the last 18 months first. "Terms" shows how the weights have moved since, against the best-placed of them that day.
| Finished | Behind Kartini | Terms v Kartini | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kartini | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Dandy's Angel | 2nd | 3½L | 5lb better off |
| Parole Officer | 5th | 13¼L | 6lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Naturalia | Terms v Naturalia | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Naturalia | 3rd | — | the yardstick |
| Kinross Claret | 14th | 45L | 7lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Flying Moonlight | Terms v Flying Moonlight | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flying Moonlight | 4th | — | the yardstick |
| Dandy's Angel | 6th | 22¼L | 2lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Parole Officer | Terms v Parole Officer | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parole Officer | 5th | — | the yardstick |
| Galistra | 12th | 52½L | 1lb worse off |
The others in that race, since
3 more meetings
| Finished | Behind Naturalia | Terms v Naturalia | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Naturalia | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Parole Officer | 6th | 4¼L | 4lb better off |
The others in that race, since
| Finished | Behind Naturalia | Terms v Naturalia | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Naturalia | 4th | — | the yardstick |
| Parole Officer | 11th | 14L | 10lb better off |
| Finished | Behind Cougar | Terms v Cougar | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cougar | 9th | — | the yardstick |
| Dandy's Angel | 13th | 8½L | same terms |
The others in that race, since
Earlier meetings: 1 race before 4 May 25, newest first
| Finished | Behind Grey Fable | Terms v Grey Fable | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grey Fable | 1st | — | the yardstick |
| Naturalia | 5th | 5L | 15lb worse off |