Nine runs without a win, pulled up on her latest start, and 18/1 in a nine-runner Class 3. On the face of it MAX OF STARS (4:20 Sedgefield, 18/1) is one to leave alone. We are going the other way.
Start with the handicapper. Her last win came at Wetherby off a mark of 115. She runs off 112 this afternoon, so she is 3lb lower than when she last got her head in front. Three pounds is not a collapse in the weights. It matters because of where she is running. Class 3 is her level, and her times have held up when the company has been this good. Some horses only look competitive in a weak race at a lower grade. She has never needed that.
Then there is the track. She has form at Sedgefield over course and distance, and she has run over this trip on good ground before, so nothing about the conditions asks her a new question. Ollie Pears has her back out 17 days after the last run.
That last run is the concern, and it is a real one. She was pulled up. But read the line before it. The figures are 4, 4 and then a second two starts ago, which is a horse running into form, not out of it. One bad afternoon in among that does not cancel the run that came just before it. If the pulled up was a one-off, she is too big. If it wasn’t, the price already allows for it and then some.
Jamie Hamilton rides.
PARK THAT (4:30 Limerick, 7/2) is a very different sort of bet. Shorter, more exposed, and his problem is the opposite of hers. He keeps running well and not winning.
He was second last time out and has been placed in three of his last five, without a win in that spell. In a handicap that pattern usually means a horse is meeting one better each time rather than going backwards. His form is better than the bare figures suggest, and 932-62 already reads fairly well. At Kilbeggan on 15 May he went down by a head, and the one that beat him has won since. It is not a line to build a house on, but it shows he was right there with a horse good enough to win again.
The conditions suit. He has run over today’s trip of two miles three and a bit on yielding ground before, and that is what Limerick has for him today. Harry Cobden rides for the Bolger yard.
The question is the 134 days since he last ran. Bolger has had him off since early summer, and whether he comes back ready to do himself justice is the one thing the form book cannot answer. We are taking 7/2 that he does.
Yesterday Queenstown (14/1) and Fighting Tears (66/1) both placed without either winning.
The two races are ten minutes apart. If Max of Stars is in the first three coming to the last at Sedgefield, the 4:30 at Limerick becomes a very easy watch.