Thirteen to eight is a short price for a horse that hasn’t been seen since the middle of June. It looks shorter still in a 17-runner Class 3 at York on good to soft ground. BEAGLE BAY (1:30 York, 13/8) deserves it. His last run was a win at Sandown on 13 June, his second in a row and his third in five starts. The horse he beat by half a length that day has since won a class 2 and is now rated 8lb higher than when they met. Another horse from his recent races has also won since. He drops below the grade he last won in, so he meets this field with form that has already been tested, and in easier company. The 118 days off is the one question. It is about fitness, not ability, and the ability has been shown.
Hector Crouch stays at York for NOBLE RAIDER (3:50 York, 7/2), and this one has been away even longer. He hasn’t run for 146 days, which is a long time for a five-furlong horse, and that is the part of the bet that needs thinking about. Everything else is in order. His last three runs read 2, 3, 1, so he has made the first three every time, and he has run over this trip before. The horse that beat him by a length and a quarter at Newmarket in May has won a class 4 since. He comes back into a field of only eight.
Two runs is all MEHMAS STAR (3:18 York, 14/1) has had. On the first he was caught near the line in a class 3 at Carlisle, the same grade as today. The 0 came in a much richer race at the Curragh. With four rivals and a big drop in company, 14/1 is too big.
Newmarket
Charlie Appleby has had 7 winners from 22 runners in the last fortnight, and STUDY OF WORDS (3:30 Newmarket, 7/1) is his runner in the class 2 over a mile and a half. His last run was at Ascot on 24 July. He finished second there, and a length behind him was a horse that has since won a class 2. That is the right level of form for a race like this, and at 7/1 it is being underrated. He has won one of his two starts at Newmarket and has run on this trip and ground before. The 77 days off counts for something, but with the yard in this sort of form it counts for less than usual. William Buick rides from stall 1.
LION OF MALI (5:20 Newmarket, 4/1) drops in grade after finishing eighth last time. The run before that was a win, and so was the one three further back. At Doncaster in September he finished a length and a half in front of a horse that has since won a class 2, and one more horse from his recent races has also won. He has form over course and distance. Two of his five career wins have come on fast ground, which is what he gets today. The concern is his mark. He is 6lb above the one he last won off, so he needs that Doncaster form to be his true level. We think it is, and class 4 is where it should tell.
Yesterday our one headline pick was unplaced.
Kempton and Dundalk under lights
HAVANA TOUCH (6:45 Kempton, 13/8) has won two of his three runs over this course and distance in the last 18 months. That is the whole case. He finished eighth last time, after a second and a win before that, and he has had 22 days since. Back on this track over a mile in a class 5 he is in his own territory, and Billy Loughnane rides from stall 5. We’ll take 13/8 about a horse who keeps winning here.
BAHIA BONITA (4:38 Kempton, 7/1) has run three times, finishing fourth, third and then first. She comes back just 20 days after that win. Horses she finished close to have since won, so the form she has been running in has stood up. Jack Jones has had 3 winners from 11 runners in the past fortnight. Callum Shepherd rides her from stall 11. A horse with three runs and her last one a win has more to come than the rest of this field, and the price doesn’t account for that.
Across the water, COASTING (6:30 Dundalk, 8/1) is a bigger price than his form deserves, because 4590 misses part of the picture. At Leopardstown in May, the horse that beat him by a length and a quarter has gone on to win, and his fourth came four starts back. The riding and training are the other reason. Luke McAteer is 18 from 112 at Dundalk in the last 12 months, which is 16% against 7% overall. David Marnane is 13 from 69 here, 19% against 10%. He has run over seven furlongs on this surface before. With 14 runners there is room for a horse at his price to get involved.
Callum Shepherd, on Bahia Bonita at 4:38, is back for HARLINGTON (7:45 Kempton, 4/1), one of seven runners over a mile and a half. He last won off 69 at Chelmsford and runs off 68 tonight. He has run four times since without winning, but the form from those runs has held up. The horse that beat him by a length at Newbury on 2 July has won since, and two more from those races have also won. He has been off for 77 days. Even so, he is a pound below his last winning mark, back on the all-weather where he has won four of his last seven starts, and in a field this small that is enough to make 4/1 the right side.